Gnee Steel (Tianjin) Co., Ltd.

How Strong Are Copper Tube Products? Strength, Temper and Pressure Explained

Aug 21, 2024

What Determines the Strength of a Copper Tube

The strength of a copper tube is not a single figure printed on a mill certificate. It is the combined result of the alloy, the temper left in the metal after the final drawing and annealing pass, the wall thickness relative to the outside diameter, and the way the tube is bent, expanded or brazed on site. Two tubes of identical outside diameter can differ in allowable working pressure by a factor of almost two simply because one is supplied soft annealed and the other hard drawn.

For this reason a copper tube should never be ordered by diameter and length alone. A complete specification names the alloy, the temper, the dimensions and the governing standard, for example ASTM B88 for seamless copper water tube, EN 1057 for copper tubes used with water and gas, or GB/T 1527 for drawn copper and copper alloy tube.

Typical Mechanical Properties of Copper Tube

The table below gives the property ranges normally quoted for seamless copper tube in the three tempers used most often in industry. The figures are typical room temperature values for C12200 phosphorus deoxidised copper and should still be checked against the certificate of the actual heat.

Temper Tensile strength 0.2% proof stress Elongation Typical service
Soft annealed, O60 about 205-250 MPa about 60-90 MPa 40% and above Bending, coiling, refrigeration lines
Half hard, H55 about 250-310 MPa about 180-250 MPa 25-35% Plumbing risers, HVAC distribution
Hard drawn, H58 about 310-380 MPa about 250-330 MPa 8-20% Straight runs, bushings, structural parts

Copper also holds useful strength across a very wide temperature band. It does not become brittle at cryogenic temperature, and its tensile strength falls only gradually up to roughly 150 degrees Celsius. Above about 200 degrees Celsius a soft annealed tube will continue to soften, so hot water and steam lines are normally specified in a hard temper or with an increased wall.

Wall Thickness, Pressure Rating and Safety Factor

For thin walls the working pressure follows p = 2 S t / (D minus 0.8 t), where S is the allowable stress, t the wall thickness and D the outside diameter. The allowable stress is a fraction of the specified minimum tensile strength, commonly one quarter for water service and a smaller fraction where vibration or refrigerant pulsation is present. Increasing the wall is therefore the most direct way to gain pressure capacity, while thinning the wall to save weight has the opposite effect and also weakens the tube against crushing at the joint.

Thermal conductivity of C12200: roughly 340-390 W/(m K), the highest of any tube metal in common industrial use.

Coefficient of thermal expansion: about 17.0-17.7 x 10^-6 per K, so expansion loops are needed on long hot runs.

Modulus of elasticity: about 110-130 GPa, which keeps a tube stiff enough to span normal hanger spacing.

Density: about 8.9 g/cm3, close to three times that of an equal aluminium section.

Fatigue, Vibration and Joint Strength

In refrigeration, compressed air and hydraulic circuits a copper tube rarely fails from a single overload. The usual failure is fatigue driven by alternating pressure and vibration and concentrated at a brazed joint, a flare or a bend. Three measures control the risk. Keep the bend radius generous, because a bend formed on a proper former keeps a more even wall than one pulled over a spring in the field. Support the line so that the natural frequency of the run does not match the compressor or pump frequency. Finally, never reheat an already brazed joint, since every extra heating cycle coarsens the grain and lowers the fatigue limit of the annealed zone.

Corrosion and Long Term Service Life

Copper earns its reputation for durability from the oxide film it forms naturally. In clean potable water an annealed or half hard tube commonly stays in service for 20 to 50 years. Difficulties appear only when the environment breaks that film: water with a pH below about 6.5 and high carbon dioxide, high free chlorine, ammonia near a brazed joint, or soil rich in sulphide. Where such conditions exist the practical answers are a heavier wall, a protective wrap, or an alloy such as cupronickel instead of plain copper. Copper tolerates seawater far better than brass, but it is not immune, and flux residue or metal swarf left inside the bore after installation will start pitting that no temper can prevent.

Strength, Weight and Design Balance

Copper will never win a strength contest against steel. Annealed copper is roughly one third as strong as mild steel and it is also heavier, so a copper tube needs a thicker wall than a steel tube carrying the same pressure. The engineering case for copper rests on other properties: the highest thermal conductivity of any common tube metal, excellent formability, a stable oxide film, and a joining process that can be carried out with a torch and no special atmosphere. Where those properties matter more than pure load capacity, copper tube is the economical choice; where the duty is dominated by pressure and abrasion, another material should be selected.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is the strength of copper tube products high compared with steel?
Relative to its weight, no. Annealed copper is about one third the strength of mild steel and is also heavier, so an equal pressure rating needs a thicker copper wall. Its real advantages are thermal conductivity, formability and corrosion resistance.

Q: Does bending a copper tube reduce its strength?
Cold bending work hardens the metal and thins the outer wall at the bend. In annealed tube this raises the local tensile strength but lowers elongation, which is why the pressure rating of a bent section is based on the reduced wall thickness and the bend radius.

Q: Which temper should be chosen for a high pressure line?
Use a hard drawn temper and, if the line is also vibrated, increase the wall rather than relying on the temper alone. A hard tube resists internal pressure and crushing better, but it cannot be coiled and needs annealed tube at the joints.

Q: How long does a copper tube last in service?
In clean water with a pH near neutral, 20 to 50 years is normal for a correctly installed tube. Aggressive water chemistry, ammonia, high chlorine or sulphide bearing soil can cut that figure sharply, and those conditions call for a protective coating or a cupronickel alloy.

Q: Does copper tube become brittle at low temperature?
No. Copper keeps its ductility at cryogenic temperature, which is why it is used for liquid nitrogen and liquid oxygen piping. The brittleness problem belongs to carbon steel, not to copper.

Q: Can a copper tube be welded instead of brazed?
It can, but brazing and soldering are preferred because they need less heat input and keep the annealed zone short. Welding raises the temperature over a wider band and softens more of the tube, so the joint area loses strength over a longer length.

goTop